NEWSROOM

You built your book of business through relationships, follow-through, and being a health insurance product expert. But here's the uncomfortable truth (9 times out of 10) before a potential employer client ever calls you: they've already visited your website and in about eight seconds, they've decided whether they want to work with you. 

A poorly performing website doesn't just fail to impress, but it can also actively cost you clients. Here are seven signs that your agency’s website might actually be working against you. We’ve also included a quick fix to correct each flaw and turn your site into a lead generation money-generating machine.

Sign #1: Your Site Isn't Mobile-Friendly

Pull up your agency website on your phone right now. If you're pinching and zooming, hunting for a menu, or waiting on a page that feels like it's loading over dial-up, your prospects already bounced.

More than 60% of web traffic today comes from mobile devices, and that includes busy HR managers and business owners searching for coverage options on their lunch break. Google also ranks mobile-first, meaning a site that isn't optimized for phones is penalized in search before a visitor even lands on it.

Quick check: Can someone fill out a contact form, find your phone number, or request a quote from your site using only their thumb? If the answer is no, you're leaving business on the table.

Quick Fix: If you noted issues with the mobile check, update your website to a mobile friendly template with responsive design. Doing this will make sure your site is optimized for today’s most used mobile browsers.

Sign #2: AI Search Can't Find You

Here's a shift most agency websites haven't caught up to yet: a growing number of your prospects aren't just Googling they're asking ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Gemini questions like "What's the best health insurance option for my 15-person company in California?"

If your site doesn't clearly answer questions like that, you won't appear in those results.
This is called Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) or Answer Engine Optimization (AEO), and it's changing how agencies get discovered. The sites that show up aren't necessarily the biggest but they're the ones that answer real broker and employer questions in plain language. Think of FAQs, resource articles, and "how it works" pages that speak directly to what your clients are searching for.

Quick fix: Add a FAQ section to your homepage or services page answering the top five questions your clients ask you on the phone. That content is gold for AI-powered search. Also check your landing page content to make sure it includes comparisons and easy scannable content. This helps AI search crawlers parse through your content more quickly.

Lastly, video explainers are gold for AI engines. You can shoot a quick 30 second explainer video on your iPhone breaking down how employers can get their team access to the best hospitals and networks in your city. This will all help boost your sites visibility in AI search prompts.

Sign #3: No Clear Calls to Action

A visitor lands on your homepage. They read a bit, maybe scroll through your services. Then what? If your site doesn't tell them what to do next in plain, direct language they'll probably leave.

Vague language like "Learn more" or "Contact us" doesn't always cut it. Strong calls to action are specific: "Get a Same-Day Quote," "Talk to a Broker," "Compare Plans for Your Team." They tell the prospect exactly what they'll get and make it easy to take the next step.

Every page on your site should have at least one clear CTA above the fold meaning visible without scrolling. If a prospect has to hunt for your phone number or figure out how to reach you, most won't bother.

Quick fix: Add a sticky header button or a prominent hero CTA with action-oriented language on every page. Then check your contact page, is it one click away from anywhere on the site?

Sign #4: Your Content Is Out of Date

If your website still references carriers, plans, or network details from two or three years ago or if there's a news section and the most recent post is from 2022, you're signaling to potential clients that you're not paying attention to the market or updating your website. In health insurance, that's a credibility killer.

This is especially important right now. With major carrier changes reshaping the California market including significant exits from the commercial group space, your clients need to know you're on top of it. Brokers and employers are actively searching for guidance. An updated blog, a market alert, or even a single well-placed homepage callout can position you as the agency that has answers.

Search engines also reward fresh content. Sites that publish regularly tend to rank higher than those that have gone quiet.

Quick fix: Add a brief market update to your blog or news page – something timely that your clients would actually find useful. Commit to one new post per month, even a short one.

Sign #5: Your Pages Load Too Slowly

In a world of instant everything, a slow website is a silent closer. Research consistently shows that more than half of mobile users abandon a site that takes longer than three seconds to load. Every extra second costs you a percentage of your site visitors – and in a competitive market, those fractions add up.

Page speed also directly affects your Google ranking. A slow site gets buried even if your content is excellent. Common culprits include uncompressed images, outdated themes, too many plugins, or a hosting plan that's simply undersized for your traffic.

Quick fix: Run your site through Google Page Speed Insights. It gives you a score and a prioritized list of exactly what's slowing you down. Share the results with a web developer and get a quote to resolve. Many of the needed fixes take less than an hour.

Sign #6: No Social Proof

Your reputation is your most valuable asset. But if a prospect lands on your website and can't find any evidence that other people trust you – no reviews, no client logos, no case studies, no testimonials – they have to take your word for it. Most won't.

Social proof is especially powerful in insurance, where trust is the whole transaction. A handful of genuine client quotes, a Google review average, or even a simple line like "Helping California businesses find coverage since 2002" goes a long way. If you serve specific industries or group sizes, say that. Specificity builds credibility.

Quick fix: Reach out to three or four satisfied clients this week and ask for a short quote you can use on your site. Even one or two authentic testimonials changes the feel of a homepage significantly.

Sign #7: It Doesn't Answer the Client's Actual Question

Here's the most common website mistake brokers make: building a site that talks about themselves instead of talking to their client. Pages full of mission statements, broker bios, and carrier logos don't answer the question the prospect actually showed up with.

That question is almost always some version of: "Can you help me figure out the right health coverage for my team without this turning into a nightmare?"

The best agency websites speak directly to that. They explain what the process looks like, what kinds of businesses they're best at helping, what happens after someone fills out the contact form, and why working with a broker beats going it alone. They write for the person reading, not for the agency doing the writing.

Quick fix: Read your homepage out loud. If it sounds like a brochure about your agency rather than a conversation with your client, rewrite the headline and first two paragraphs from the client's perspective. One afternoon of editing can transform how a visitor feels when they land.

Your website should be working for you around the clock answering questions, building credibility, and making it easy for the right clients to reach you. If it's not doing those three things, it's costing you business you'll never even know you lost.

The good news: most of these fixes don't require a full redesign. Start with one sign from this list, make the improvement, and build from there. Small changes, made consistently, add up to a site that converts.

About the Author
Kalup Alexander is Digital Marketing Director for The Word & Brown Companies. He holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in New Media Communications and Marketing from Oregon State University. He has been at The Word & Brown Companies since 2014.